# Calculators in the Classroom?

~~www.mathwithoutborders.com ~~

By David Chandler, Math Without Borders

A concerned mother recently wrote to ask me if my Math Without Borders courses allowed students to use calculators. The answer is “Yes”, but not because I think students should use a crutch. Calculators, and technology in general, open doors that would likely never be opened any other way. It’s like requiring that a carpenter never use power tools. Yes, every board could be sawed by hand, and yes, it used to be done that way, and yes, the Amish still do it that way, but who, among the rest of us, don’t value our power tools? Technology is not just a crutch. It can give us wings!

“When I was in school…” we used slide rules and a book of tables for logarithms and trig functions. We spent weeks of valuable class time learning how to break down a number into its “characteristic” and “mantissa” to look up its logarithm, how to interpolate the tables to squeeze an extra digit of precision by, literally, “reading between the lines,” and then we had to learn a whole new technique to find logarithms of numbers less than 1. What most students learned from all this is how “hard” logarithms are, and what they probably missed, is how useful they are.

Today, I start the introduction of logarithms by showing students how to type in a number in their calculator and find the “log” button, or if they need natural logarithms, the “ln” button. Having mastered that, we turn our attention to solving problems involving inflation, compound interest, exponential decay, and the many occurrences of logarithms in natural processes, such as perceived loudness (decibels), perceived star brightness (magnitude scale), and the transformation of sound frequency into the musical scale. A calculator with a log button is a power tool; log tables are hand saws.

I don’t stop with calculators. Anyone who takes my classes comes out knowing how to use a spreadsheet. Spreadsheets are not just for financial calculations. They are a way to program many kinds of problems that involve repetitive computations. Archimedes computed the value of pi to the precision of 3.14 by finding the perimeter of a regular hexagon, then doubling the sides repeatedly to find the perimeters of 12, 24, 48, and finally 96-sided regular polygons. He did all this by hand without even decimal notation at his disposal. Today, too often, students are simply told that pi = 3.14159… without any hint of how that number was determined. It would be foolhardy to make kids repeat Archimedes’ feat, by hand, but the sequence of transformations that lead from the perimeter of a polygon to the perimeter of a polygon with twice the number of sides, is actually not that difficult. It can be programmed into a single line of a spreadsheet calculation. Duplicate the calculation by dragging the row of formulas down the page and students can see the value of pi emerge, to the full precision of the numbers used in the spreadsheet. What was once mysterious is now seen as the result of a concrete series of computations. Power tools make the difference.

Students in Algebra 1 learn to solve two equations with two unknowns. In Algebra 2 they take on 3 equations with 3 unknowns, with a hint of how the process might be extended to 4, 5, or even more unknowns. But I prefer power tools. After solving a few sample problems, I prefer to have them put their effort into programming a spreadsheet to carry out the process in a systematic way for any equations that may be encountered. Once programmed, you can type in the coefficients and see the answers immediately. I walk my students through programming a spreadsheet to solve for 5 unknowns and challenge them to extend it to 10 unknowns. (I have posted videos with this pair of lessons on YouTube. Go to http://mathwithoutborders.com and scroll down to Algebra 2 for links.) By the time they have created the tool, and verify that it works, they will understand the process, probably better than students who have spent hours in repetitive drill. They have also added something to their toolkit that can make life easier when they actually need these skills in future science classes.

My favorite power tool for high school math (Jr high through college, actually) is Geogebra (available free from http://geogebra.org). If a spreadsheet is like a table saw, then Geogebra is like a router, with all the fancy attachments! Geometry and algebra are brought together in a complementary way. Anything created with the geometric tools are displayed as equations in the “Algebra View.” Equations entered algebraically are displayed graphically in the “Geometry View” as well. Algebra becomes visual and geometry becomes analytical. Raw data, from a science lab class, can be entered through the built-in spreadsheet, plotted graphically, and analyzed algebraically with a built-in statistical toolkit. Variables in equations entered algebraically can be manipulated graphically as “sliders.” Ever wonder how the coefficients in a polynomial affect its shape? Create sliders named a, b, c, d, and e, use those names for the coefficients in a 4th degree polynomial in the algebra view, then play! New insights and new questions will emerge from such play. Following up on the questions is what we call “mathematics.”

The long awaited Geogebra version 5.0 is now out! Version 5 includes 3-D graphics. You can now plot cones, cylinders, spheres, and planes with any orientation in space, see how they intersect, and spin them around to see them from any perspective. Have you heard that you can slice a cone with a plane at an angle and get an ellipse? With Geogebra Ver. 5 you can construct a cone, slice it with a plane, see the ellipse, and see the ellipse transform into a parabola or hyperbola as the tilt of the plane is changed. I started using Geogebra heavily when I was developing the Math Without Borders Precalculus class. Last spring I went back and completely reworked my Geometry course to take full advantage of Geogebra, and I am now using it daily as I develop my Calculus course, where it replaces tiny graphing calculators with full size keyboard and display, and more powerful software.

While being useful up through calculus and beyond, Geogebra has features that are accessible and useful even to Jr. high and elementary students. Start with simple geometric constructions. Add in the ability to perform geometric transformations: reflections, rotations, translations, etc. Add in the ability to create animations. Encapsulate a sequence of construction steps as a single new button in the toolbox. There is plenty here to keep a precocious 5th grader interested, while enabling a calculus student, or a calculus teacher(!) to both broaden and deepen mathematical insight and understanding.

Calculators. Do I favor their use in class? Absolutely. It’s not about skipping the multiplication tables. It’s about opening new doors. And don’t stop with just calculators! DC

### Recent Posts

- Willowbend Books – Morgan Horse Series and More
- Bon Voyage France!
- Astro-Naut Aqua Naut, How Space Science and Sea Science Interact
- Shakespeare for All!
- Admissions Advice for College-bound Special Needs Students

### Categories

- 'cello
- #1775 Rebellion
- #American geography resources
- #American history
- #David Chandler
- #David Skaggs
- #George Washington
- #Hawaiian History review
- #Jewish immigrant
- #Math Without Borders
- #Revolutionary War
- #SumBlox
- #www.sumblox.com
- 14 Rooms
- 4th grade
- 4th Grade Achievements
- Academy Games
- Academy of Botanical Drawing
- Accent and Acting Resources
- ACT
- Acting
- Acting as study
- Acting curriculum
- Acting for children
- Addition & Subtraction
- Addition aid
- Adele Tolley Wilson
- Administration aids
- Admissions Advice
- Adult reading aids
- Adult Reading Online
- Adventure reading
- Affordable resource
- Affordable resources
- Affordable Web-based Reading
- Alan Delk
- Alaska
- Alaska Geography
- Alaska History
- Alaska Statehood
- Alesia Blackwood
- Algebra aid
- Algebra curriculum
- alternative education
- Amanda J. Murray
- America's Math Teacher
- American Academy
- American Cap & Gown
- American geography
- American History
- American History board game
- American Sign Language
- Anchorage
- Android
- Animal Anatomy
- Animal care
- Animal interests
- AP Biology
- AP Chemistry
- AP Science
- Arizona
- Art
- Art lessons
- Art training
- Arthurian legend
- Arts
- Astronomy
- Aunt Phil's Trunk
- Bacteria
- Bad Wolf Press
- Bar Mitzvah
- Basic Grammar
- Basic Math
- Basic math app
- basic Spanish
- Basket making
- Basketweaving
- Bat Mitzvah
- Beacon College
- Bead stringing
- beginning math
- Beginning Reading
- Beginning writing
- Beowulf
- Berklee College of Music
- Beth Ellen Nash
- Bilbo
- Blog
- Board game creative writing
- Boston
- Botanical Drawing curriculum
- botanical illustration
- Botanical specimens
- Brain development
- Brain Stimulation
- Brain training
- British History
- British Regular Army
- bullies
- bullying
- Bunker Hill
- Business courses online
- Business Curriculum
- Business Education
- by Emerson Sandow
- by Joseph Grayhaim
- by Michael Leppert
- C.S. Lewis
- Cadena Smith
- Cadena Smith Enterprises
- Cardio health
- CE Credits
- Chambers Stevens
- Character building
- Charlottesville Virginia
- chemistry book review
- Chemistry for college
- Chemistry for high school
- childrens nature books
- Choctaw
- Chris Farina
- Chris Vasquez
- Christian curriculum
- Christian fiction
- Christian Instruction
- Christopher Marlowe
- Classical Drama
- Classroom aids
- Classroom crafts and arts
- Classroom writing ideas
- classroom writing resources
- Classroomreviewsnow
- Classroomreviewsnow.com
- CODiE Award
- College Admissions
- College Counselor
- College for Disabled Students
- College prep
- College Preparation
- Common Core math aids
- Communication
- Composers
- Computer Skills
- Conceptual Learning
- Conlonial America
- Continental Army
- Continuing Education Credits
- Cool Math
- Cool Tools Math
- Crafts
- Create a Math Environment
- Create-a-Story
- Creative thinking
- Creative writing board game
- Critical Thinking
- Crystal Reed
- Culinary arts
- Current events
- Curriculum
- Customized Science Curriculum
- Dabble board game review
- Dabble Word Game
- Daily Grams
- David Chandler
- David Skaggs
- Deaf resources
- Decimals
- Diana Yacobi
- Dianne Knesek
- Dick Parman
- Discounts
- discovering black bears
- Dissection
- Division aid
- Dr. Aditya Nagrath
- Dr. Alene Harris
- Dr. Alvaro Arias
- Dr. Ed Myers
- Dr. Phillips
- Dr. Suzanne Lahl
- Dr. Wanda Phillips
- Drama
- Drama as study
- drama performances
- Drama resources
- Drama Teaching
- Drawing
- DVD
- DVDs programs
- Early geography
- Early Literacy
- Early Music Education
- Early Reading
- Early reading DVDs
- Early reading program
- Early spelling
- Early writing
- Earth Science
- Easy Grammar
- Easy Grammar review
- eBooks
- Ed.D.
- Educational board game on iPad
- Educational board games
- educational games
- Educational Toy
- Educational toys
- Edward DeVore
- Elementary Astronomy
- elementary creative writing
- Elementary Math
- elementary math
- Elementary math curriculum
- elementary math games
- Elementary Math iPad app
- elementary math online
- elementary math review by Emerson Sandow
- elementary math workbooks
- Elementary reading
- Elementary Science
- Elementary Spanish
- Elephant Learning
- Emerson Sandow
- Emerson Sandow review
- English
- English Language Learners
- English skills
- English Spanish storybook
- English Vocabulary
- Environment
- Environmental Education
- Equestrian
- Eschar Publications
- European Travel
- Evelyn Fannin
- Exercise
- Family activities
- Family Farm board game
- Family projects
- Farm Fresh Delivered to You
- Farm Fresh to You
- Farm Game review by Emerson Sandow
- Field Trips
- Finance 101
- Fine Art curriculum
- Fluency
- Foreign Language
- Fraction Fun
- Fractions
- France
- Free covers
- Free curriculum online
- free grammar pages
- Free online resources
- free pages
- Free Reading improvement
- Free reading trial
- Free sales
- Free Sample
- Free Sample Lessons
- Free Sample Lessons Online
- Free sample vocabulary lessons
- Free samples
- Free Student Resources
- Free Teacher materials
- Free Teacher Resources
- Free Trial
- Free Video lessons
- Free website resource
- Frodo
- Fruits and Vegetables
- Gandalf
- General George Washington
- Geography
- Geometry curriculum
- global thinking
- Goal-orientation
- gobbledygook
- Gold Fever
- Graduation Supplies
- grammar assessments
- Grammar book review
- grammar curriculum
- Greek Morphemes
- Grieg
- Guitar
- Guitar lessons
- Hawaiian History
- Hearing Impaired resources
- Hebrew
- Hebrew reading
- Hessians
- High School Biology
- high school chemistry
- high school creative writing
- High School History
- High school math
- high school math aid
- High School Math online
- High School Science
- High school vocabulary
- History
- history teacher resources
- Hobbits
- Hollywood
- Home Ec
- Homeschool Almanac
- Homeschool crafts
- Horizon Globe
- Horse riding
- I love math!
- IL
- Illustration
- Inspired Education
- Inspired Education Magazine
- Inspired Education Magzine
- InspiredEducation.com
- Instructor Resources
- Intelligent Toys
- Interactive video reading program
- iPad
- iPad apps
- iPad math
- iPhone
- iPhone math app
- Israel
- Izzit.org
- J.R.R. Tolkien
- Jacques Cousteau
- James E. Williams
- Jennifer Nairne
- Jennifer Nairne review
- Jennifer Swanson
- Jennifer Swanson books
- Jewish culture
- John Hunter
- Joseph Grayhaim
- JS Bach
- Judy Keeney
- Jump Rope Store
- Justin Frank Polgar
- K-12
- K-12 Music Theory
- K-8 math daily review
- K-8 math teacher resources
- K5 Learning
- Kathryn Sullivan
- Katie Kimball
- kids cook real food
- Kindergarten Literacy
- Kindergarten reading
- Kindle
- kinesthetic learner
- Kinesthetic learning
- King Arthur
- Kitchen math
- Lab Supplies
- Laboratory experience
- Landmark College
- Language Arts
- Latin Morphemes
- Laurel Bill
- Learning Styles
- Lexington and Concord
- Liberty
- Life on the Farm Board Game
- Life Science
- Literacy
- Lord of the Rings
- Los Gatos
- M.Ed.
- manipulative way
- manual dexterity teaching
- Map of the world
- Map of USA
- Maps
- Marine life
- Marvin Reynolds
- Mary Leppert
- Math
- math book review
- math building program
- Math concept
- math concepts
- math curricula
- Math curriculum
- Math daily review
- Math Enjoyable
- Math Essentials
- math for ages 2-12
- Math FREE Trial
- math game subscription service
- Math Games
- math games online
- Math in the Kitchen
- Math K-5
- math lessons
- Math practice app
- Math resources
- math results guaranteed
- math review
- math review by Emerson Sandow
- Math Supplement
- math supplemental
- math teacher
- math teacher aids
- math teachers
- math teachers aid
- math teaching aids
- math tutors online
- Math videos
- Math Without Borders
- Mathematics
- MathWithoutBorders.com
- Matthew Blackwood
- Memorization
- memorization tips
- Memory Improvement
- Memory Mark™ tool
- Merlin
- Metric Measurement
- Mexican Spanish
- Mexican storybook
- Michael Leppert
- Michael Leppert review
- Michael Leppert reviews
- middle school creative writing
- middle school math
- Middle School reading
- Middle School science resources
- middle school vocabulary
- Middle School writing
- Middle-earth
- mindful math daily review
- Miscellaneous
- MjL
- MjL review
- Mona Balogh
- Monologues
- Monologues for children
- Montessori Math help
- Mountain Math
- Ms. Owens
- Ms. Vivian Owens
- Mt. Math
- Multiplication aid
- Multiply & Divide
- Music
- Music Education
- Music Lessons
- Music Lessons Los Angeles
- Music Programs
- Music Reading
- Music students
- Music Teacher Resources
- Music Teaching Materials
- Music Theory
- Musical Theatre curriculum
- Nancy K. Lewkowicz
- National Science Teachers Association
- Native American crafts
- Native American culture
- Nature
- nature books for children
- NEEMO
- No Drama College Counseling
- Nook
- Old and New Testament
- Olivia Maria Braida
- Olympic training
- OM Braida
- On-line program
- Online Business Courses
- Online Christian Academy
- Online Christian learning
- Online Ed
- Online Education
- Online Education and Independent Study Programs
- Online Free Reading Lessons
- Online High School Math curriculum
- Online K-12 academy
- Online learning
- Online Literacy
- Online Math
- online math games
- Online Music Theory
- Online Programs
- Online Spelling
- Online Teachers Manual
- online-ed-isps
- Organic produce
- Organizing
- Orton-Gillingham
- P.E.
- pen and ink
- Penmanship curriculum
- Periodic Table
- Perplexi®
- Ph.D.
- PhD
- Phonics
- Phyllis Downing Carlson
- Physical Education
- Physical Fitness
- pianist
- Piano lessons
- Plum Gum
- Poetry
- political games
- Political Geography
- Pre-calculus curriculum
- problem-solving
- Professional Development
- Professional Teachers
- Professor Jay Burman
- Public Speaking
- QSL
- Quality Science Labs
- Ratios
- Read Hebrew Now
- Read Right Systems
- ReadBar™
- reading
- Reading Aids
- Reading comprehension
- Reading foreign language
- Reading Games
- Reading improvement
- Reading middle school
- Reading remedial
- Reading remedies
- Reading Review
- Reading Specialist
- Reading success
- Reading Teachers Free Materials
- Reading teens
- Reading Tools
- Reading Workbooks
- Readorium
- Ready to Teach
- recording arts
- Remedial math
- Remedial reading
- review
- Review by Emerson Sandow
- review by Janet Esposito
- review by Jennifer Nairne
- Review by Michael Leppert
- Review by MjL
- Review by Valerie Schuetta
- review of Basic Math Solutions
- review of Conceptual Learning by Michael Leppert
- review of Create-a-Story
- review of creative writing board game
- review of Easy Grammar
- Review of See-n-Read
- review of SumBlox
- review of Unlock Math
- Reviews
- Reviews by Michael Leppert
- revolutionary math learning program
- Richard Garcia
- Rosalia Films
- Samantha Timmerman
- Sarasota Florida art schools
- SAT
- SAT Prep
- SAT score improvement
- sax lessons
- Science
- science
- Science & Math
- Science and Math
- science curriculum
- Science Education
- Science experiments
- Science for children
- Science Kits
- Science Lab Kits
- Science Literacy Program
- Science Musical Play
- Science programs
- Science resources for teachers
- science review by Michael Leppert
- science songs
- Science Supplies
- Science teacher resources
- Scientific Learning
- Scientific memorization
- Scottsdale
- See-n-Read Reading Tools
- See-n-Spell™
- Shakespeare
- Shakespeare's Plays
- Shiller
- Sight-reading
- Signing
- Sir Francis Bacon
- Skipping rope
- Songs that teach
- SoundLife Music
- SoundLife Music Academy
- Sourdough starter
- Spanish English storybook
- Spanish for kids
- Spanish vocabulary
- Special Ed Reading
- Special Ed Reading Program
- Special Ed. Math
- Special Needs College
- special needs math
- Spelling
- Spelling aid
- Spelling board game
- Spelling Reference Guide
- Sports training
- Star gazing
- STEM
- STEM Toys
- Streamable Learning
- streaming field trips
- Student Writing
- Study habits
- Study skills
- Subtraction aid
- Sujoy Spencer
- SumBlox
- Supplemental Math app
- T.V. acting
- Teach cooking
- Teacher crafts resources
- Teacher Resources
- teacher writing resources
- teaching American history
- Teaching Easy Grammar
- teaching history
- teaching math
- teaching science
- Teaching Shakespeare
- team building
- teamwork
- Test Prep
- The Arts
- Theatre Arts
- Title II
- Tsunamis
- Tuxedo Publishing
- Unit Studies
- University Admissions
- University of Denver
- University of New Hampshire
- Up-Words
- Up-Words Reading Program
- Valerie Schuetta
- Valerie Schuetta M.Ed.
- Venable School
- Verbal communication
- Video math
- Video Math Lessons
- viola
- violin
- Visual learning
- Vivian Owens
- Vocabulary
- Vocabulary aids
- Vocabulary board game
- Vocabulary building
- Vocabulary Building program
- vocabulary building programs
- Voice lessons
- Wanda C Phillips
- Wanda Phillips
- watercolor
- We R Fun Board Games
- Wings To Soar
- Wooden Planks Toys
- Word Recognition
- Work Workshop
- world affairs
- World geography
- world government
- World Peace Game
- Writing curriculum
- Writing projects
- writing review
- Written communication
- www.american-academy.com
- www.basicmathsolutions.com
- www.createpress.com
- www.easygrammar.com
- www.escharpublications.com
- www.homeschoolalmanac.com
- www.homeschoolmagazine.com
- www.homeschoolnewslink.com
- www.inspirededucationmagazine.com
- www.mtmath.com
- www.readhebrewnow.com
- www.readytoteach.com
- www.roasliafilms.com
- www.schoolmadesimple.com
- www.see-n-read.com
- www.sujoystrings.com
- www.sumboxes.com
- www.tutoringforreading.com
- www.unlockmath.com
- www.werfungames.com
- www.worldpeacegame.org
- Young child literacy
- young child math
- young child reading